Broken Bat - Bug Reports: Winning Pitcher

Forum >> Bug Reports >> Winning Pitcher

Post ID	Date & Time	Game Date	Function

#31291	02/27/2016 4:10:08 pm
mhk Joined: 11/04/2013 Posts: 62 Inactive	Hi this game: http://brokenbat.org/game/1963012 Why is Cardenas credited with the win ? The score was 5-2 when Colombo left the game, it was 7-2 whem Cardenas entered it, the final result was 8-2. upps, sorry , didn´t want to post this in the bug forum, should have been discussions, but it´s around 1 am sunday in germany and I´m drunk Updated Saturday, February 27 2016 @ 4:18:37 pm PST

#31293	02/27/2016 4:27:04 pm
admin Joined: 01/27/2010 Posts: 5023 Administrator	Colombo didn't pitch five innings as the starter, so he's not qualified to win the game. Steve

#33650	04/24/2016 3:34:03 pm
amalric7 Joined: 01/20/2016 Posts: 2259 New York Lancers IV.2	Here's something, same topic so I'm using this thread rather than start a new one. This game. My starter Alcantar gave up a home run to start the 5th inning and was pulled. Mooney came in and threw four pitches, giving up another solo homer. He was pulled. Solomon comes in and pitches two innings, and the score remains 5-3 to me while he is in the game. So Solomon gets the win? No, Mooney did, and he didn't even get an out! That can't be right, can it?

#33651	04/24/2016 3:55:08 pm
quanin Joined: 03/16/2016 Posts: 196 Cleveland Thunder V.6	Yeah, that's a legit bug. The official rule is most effective pitcher. Since an out wasn't recorded, that pitcher wasn't effective. No win for you.

#33656	04/24/2016 6:43:30 pm
DaveCool Joined: 02/28/2015 Posts: 141 Inactive	On the surface, I would agree that Solomon would get the W, but I believe that the rule is that a starter needs to complete 5 innings. It could be whoever pitches after the starter in that case.

#33659	04/24/2016 8:02:29 pm
admin Joined: 01/27/2010 Posts: 5023 Administrator	Yes, the starter wouldn't get the win if he doesn't go 5 innings. The algorithm isn't subjective enough to assign it to the "best" relief pitcher. Steve

#33662	04/25/2016 2:16:57 am
amalric7 Joined: 01/20/2016 Posts: 2259 New York Lancers IV.2	Ah, thanks for the clarification. It was only spring training but I did wonder how this would be during regular season games. Ultimately I'd take the W then, regardless of who gets it!

#33685	04/26/2016 1:29:39 am
quanin Joined: 03/16/2016 Posts: 196 Cleveland Thunder V.6	Steve, the way I read the official rule is the relieving pitcher needs to have recorded at least 1 (preferably more) outs to be considered effective. IE: If B relieves A in the 5th, walks two, then C comes on and retires the next three, C gets credit for the win. Could something like that be a possibility?

#33717	04/27/2016 2:58:22 am
amalric7 Joined: 01/20/2016 Posts: 2259 New York Lancers IV.2	I'm wondering if "The algorithm isn't subjective enough to assign it to the "best" relief pitcher" applies here too.