Discussion Forum

Forum >> Discussions >> Analyzing the Draft Pick Pool   Bookmark This Forum Thread

Post ID Date & Time Game Date Function
Tv4IE
Joined: 10/22/2013
Posts: 95

Inactive

Broken Bat Baseball
slugfest2015, I'm assuming you mean the one I drafted this season... Sadly, the reason I released him was because I currently have a surplus in the 2B position in both the Major and Minor league level.
GreenYoshi
Joined: 07/26/2013
Posts: 61

Brookhaven Mustangs
III.3

Broken Bat Baseball
Hey, I'm new to the forums but been around the game for a couple years. I thought I'd contribute to this post. My preference is college guys. Those in asterisks come from the other pools.

2021 Picks
14 (1) --- 21 (C)
13 (2) --- 22 (SS) 22 (2B)
12 (2) --- 22 (RHP) 21(RHP)
11 (2) --- 20 (OF) 20 (SS)
10 (2) --- 22 (C) 21(OF)

2020 Picks
14 (1) --- 21 (RHP)
13 (2) --- 21 (LHP) 22 (SS)
12 (4) --- 21 (1B) 20 (LHP) 20 (LHP) 22(LHP)
11 (2) --- 22 (OF) 20 (SS)
10 (1) --- 21 (RHP)

2019 Picks (Really Bad Draft Season)
12 (7) --- 22 (C) 21 (RHP) 20 (OF) 22 (OF) 22 (OF) 22 (2B) 20 (OF)
11 (2) --- 21 (LHP) 21(SS)
10 (1) --- 21 (RHP)

2018 Picks
14 (2) --- 20 (C) 22 (SS)
13 (5) --- 20 (SS) 22 (LHP) 21 (3B) 20 (RHP) 20 (RHP)
12 (1) --- 20 (OF)
11 (2) --- 21 (RHP) 21 (LHP)

2017 Picks
13 (4) --- 21 (RHP) 22 (RHP) 22 (2B) 16 (2B)*
12 (3) --- 20 (1B) 17 (LHP)* 20 (OF)
11 (3) --- 20 (C) 21 (SS) 19 (SS)*

2016 Picks
15 (1) --- 21 (OF)
14 (1) --- 21 (2B)
13 (4) --- 22 (RHP) 20 (C) 20 (RHP) 21 (OF)
12 (0)
11 (3) --- 20 (SS) 20 (SS) 19 (RHP)*
10 (1) --- 21 (RHP)

2015 Picks
14 (2) --- 21 (3B) 20 (RHP)
13 (1) --- 21 (OF)
12 (4) --- 20 (SS) 22 (RHP) 22 (LHP) 22 (OF)
11 (2) --- 20 (C) 20 (2B)
10 (1) --- 22 (RHP)
MukilteoMike
Joined: 08/09/2014
Posts: 3294

Inactive

Broken Bat Baseball
2021:
14-1
13-0
12-2
11-4
10-1

2020:
14-2
13-1
12-1
11-5
10-1

2019:
14-0
13-4
12-2
11-4
10-0

I've been looking at this myself recently. Despite what people think, these don't even out over time. It will be interesting to see what we find.
dwindacatcher
Joined: 04/03/2014
Posts: 633

Inactive

Broken Bat Baseball
2021:

15: 1
14: 1
13:
12: 3
11: 2
10: 1
9: 1

2020:

15:
14: 1
13: 4
12: 4
11:
10: 1

2019:

15: 1
14: 1
13: 3
12: 3
11: 1
10: 1

2018:

15:
14: 2
13:
12: 4
11: 2
10: 1
9: 1

Totals:

15: 2
14: 5
13: 7
12: 14
11: 5
10: 4
9: 2


my drafts look pretty good like this. Real problem is that most of those low ones were all the pitching I drafted.
Favuz
Joined: 02/26/2014
Posts: 638

Oxnard Sunsets
IV.3

Broken Bat Baseball
Sounds interesting, here are my statisctics from 2017 (when i took the team).
in 2017 i drafted a player with 12 pot and now is 104 SI (13 pot), but i listed him as 12

2021:

15: 0
14: 2
13: 1
12: 4
11: 2
10: 0

Draftees Kept: 5/9

2020:

15: 0
14: 2
13: 2
12: 2
11: 4
10: 0

Draftees Kept: 4/10

2019:

15: 1
14: 1
13: 2
12: 3
11: 1
10: 2

Draftees Kept: 6/10

2018:

15: 2
14: 1
13: 2
12: 4
11: 1
10: 0

Draftees Kept: 7/10

2017:

15: 0
14: 0
13: 2
12: 8
11: 0
10: 0

Draftees Kept: 8/10

Total:

15: 3
14: 6
13: 9
12: 21
11: 8
10: 2

Draftees Kept: 30/49


EDIT: one side note. Of the 9 14+ players only one is a pitcher. drafting quality piching seems harder (at least for me).


Updated Sunday, March 15 2015 @ 9:39:11 am PDT
Jynxed
Joined: 08/26/2013
Posts: 284

Inactive

Broken Bat Baseball
I didn't get super deep into the actual players but here are the potential and averages for each year. Looks like I took a couple years off or something based on the numbers lol. I guess the overall numbers the last 2 seasons aren't as bad as it felt but 2020 did suck and I am probably carrying some annoyance with it on every pick this year heh.

2012 AVG:12.4
14:1
13:2
12:1
11:0
10:1

2013 AVG: 10.3
14:0
13:0
12:1
11:0
10:1
09:1

2014 AVG: 13
13: 2

2015 AVG: 12
14:1
13:1
12:2
11:1
10:1

2016 AVG: 12.7
14:1
13:3
12:3
11:0
10:0

2017 AVG: 11.8
14:0
13:3
12:3
11:2
10:1

2018 AVG: 11.6
14:0
13:2
12:1
11:3
10:1

2019 AVG:12.3
14:2
13:3
12:2
11:0
10:2

2020 AVG:11.9
14:1
13:0
12:5
11:1
10:1

2021 AVG: 11.9
14:1
13:2
12:2
11:3
10:1

Updated Sunday, March 15 2015 @ 8:39:17 pm PDT
Peekay
Joined: 03/26/2014
Posts: 146

Inactive

Broken Bat Baseball
Can only go back to 2018 as that was my first full season.

2021 AVG 12.6
14 - 1
13 - 4
12 - 2
11 - 1

2020 AVG 12.4
14 - 2
13 - 2
12 - 4
11 - 2

2019 AVG 12.6
15 - 1
14 - 3
12 - 4
11 - 1
10 - 1

2018 AVG 12.1
13 - 3
12 - 5
11 - 2

Remarkably consistent overall average for me (though different ways of getting there).
I remember 2018 being a terrible year for me and only 1 guy survives on my roster.

I believe there was too much talent coming through at one point (every team shouldn't be full of 13+ Potential guys in my opinion) so if there has been a slow reduction it's probably for the best.
Tiger504
Joined: 06/17/2014
Posts: 1314

Kalamazoo Bloody Tigers
III.4

Broken Bat Baseball
I wasn't going to do this because I am okay with the shrunken draft pool but I actually found it to be an informative exercise. And yes the draft pool did shrink for this season. However after looking at the available data I am not convinced the smaller pool will actually have the impact I guessed it would, namely an overall reduction in average potential of players.
I will post my draft stats next.
Tiger504
Joined: 06/17/2014
Posts: 1314

Kalamazoo Bloody Tigers
III.4

Broken Bat Baseball
2021 12.0 avg
15-1
14
13-1
12-4
11-2
10-1

2020 11.7 avg
15-1
14
13-1
12-3
11-3
10-2

2019 12.8 avg
14-2
13-4
12-4

2018 12.1 avg
14-2
13-1
12-1
11-2
10-1

Totals
15-2
14-4
13-7
12-12
11-7
10-4

15 out of 36 picks remain on my roster currently including one major leaguer who is a 20 game winner this season.

Updated Sunday, March 15 2015 @ 8:10:10 pm PDT


Updated Sunday, March 15 2015 @ 8:18:37 pm PDT
Balbinjj
Joined: 05/27/2014
Posts: 213

Appleton Foxes
III.1

Broken Bat Baseball
2021
15-
14
13-1
12-7
11-
10-


Previous Page | Show All |